can you make brownies in a toaster oven

Can you make brownies in a toaster oven? There is so much you can do with a toaster oven, but is making brownies one of them?

Due to their simplicity and the lack of any particularly unusual ingredients, brownies are always among the best desserts to enjoy at any time of day.  

But you may wonder, “can brownies be baked in a toaster oven?”

There has always been confusing info about what should and should not be cooked in a toaster oven. But how about baking brownies?

Yes, you can make brownies in a toaster oven, but you need to follow the right cooking guidelines to get the best result. 

Can You Make Brownies in a Toaster Oven or Not?

brownies in a toaster oven

When you crave brownies, all you have to do is get your toaster oven out and get it done quickly. 

But while it is possible to use it to make brownies, you need to keep some important things in mind.

For instance, you need to know that a toaster oven is likely to heat up much faster than your standard kitchen oven. 

Therefore, you have to be careful while baking. 

Similarly, you have to use the right baking pan, usually a smaller one, or go with disposable aluminum pans to handle the baking process better. 

Can You Use a Convection Toaster Oven to Bake Brownies?

Yes, it is possible to make use of your convection toaster oven for baking brownies at home.

In a convection oven, heated air is pushed around by a fan inside the oven. 

using convection toaster to bake brownies

Also, convection ovens are around 25% more efficient than conventional ovens while baking. 

So yes, you may use them for anything, including brownies.

How to Do It?

Here is what to do when you want to bake brownies in your convection toaster oven.

  • Preheat your oven for 5-10 minutes until it reaches 300 F.
  • Add some butter or use non-fat frying spray to the pan.
  • Now, you should bake brownies using your preferred method.

Ideally, you should bake the pan for 25 minutes at 250F. 

When that happens, you can increase the heat to speed up the process. 

Wait until the brownies have cooled completely in the pan before trying to remove them. 

Can You Bake Brownies in a Toaster Oven?

toaster oven brownies

You certainly can achieve that; in fact, it is a good idea to try it, as it helps you prepare delicious brownies in a short time. 

How to Do It?

  • Turn the oven temperature up to 350 F.
  • Take a large container and combine all of the dry ingredients.
  • Mix in the coffee, butter, egg yolks, and vanilla.
  • Keep mixing until you get a smooth consistency.
  • Add chocolate, either in the form of chips or chunks.
  • Combine everything and pour it into a buttered mini-baking dish.
  • Bake them for 15 minutes if you like your brownies gooey in the middle.
  • Bake them for 20 if you prefer a bready center.
  • Wait 5 minutes to let your brownies cool off a little and then dish them out.
Tip: You can always think of adding a little more cocoa powder to boost the chocolatey flavor.

How Long Do Brownies Take to Cook in a Toaster Oven?

Brownies can be baked in a toaster oven at 350F for around 15 to 20 minutes.

So, 15 minutes is all you need to bake brownies that are chewy and gooey. 

But, if you prefer a uniformly cakey texture, baking for about 20 minutes will do the trick.

What Can You Cook in a Toaster Oven Besides Brownies?

what can you cook

You should be able to bake anything in a toaster oven if you reduce the size and amount of your baking project.

There are a number of ways in which a toaster oven excels above a conventional oven. 

The fact that it is on the little side means it heats up rapidly. 

Due to the proximity of the top and bottom heat sources, you can cook most things in no time.

Some models even have a happy “ding” and shut off after the amount of time you have set them for. 

To take full advantage of this appliance’s capabilities, why not use it more often? 

Here are a few nice things to bake in your toaster oven: 

Roast Some Chicken

roasted chicken

A spatchcocked Cornish fowl may be roasted on a toaster tray just as easily as chicken nuggets.

The method is identical to that of a standard roasting oven.

Keep cooking until the internal temperature reaches 165F and you are done! 

Try Some Bacon

baked bacon

It is just as simple to enjoy bacon using your toaster oven.

Spread some strips out on the rack that has the tray underneath, and cook until they reach the crispiness you like.

Be sure to line the lower tray with aluminum foil for simple cleanup. 

Try Fish Fillets

baked fish fillet

Since it takes little time to prepare, fish is great for heating in a toaster oven.

Do not be reluctant to experiment with your preferred variety. 

Bake Some Beans

baked beans

It does not take long for the heat to penetrate those tiny green beans and get them ready in no time.  

You can easily reheat them in a roasting pan in a single layer. 

If you want to impress your guests, toss them in some garlic oil right before serving. 

Mix Some Sausage and Peppers

baked sausage and peppers

Take some peppers with sliced onions and arrange them nicely in the bottom of your toaster oven with your Italian sausages resting on top.

Just make sure you do not let anything burn by stirring the vegetables a few times during the roasting process.

Tip: Always ensure you keep the toaster oven door closed securely and it is advisable to double-check before you turn it on to avoid any mishap. 

Roast Spicy Almonds

roast some spicy almonds

Your toaster oven is not just for baking brownies, but it can also roast nuts as well.

Spread some almonds in a single layer and toast them in the oven until they are golden and aromatic.

Then, add some sweetener, such as sugar, maple syrup, or honey, along with some salt and spice such as chile powder or cinnamon. 

What Should You Not Use When Baking Brownies in a Toaster Oven?

Now you have discovered how many delicacies you can cook using your toaster oven. 

But, do not rush because you should remember what not to use when baking brownies or other desserts.

No matter what you are baking, you should avoid using the following materials:

  • Cardboard
  • Paper towels
  • Plastic lids
  • Paper plates
  • Styrofoam

At the same time, you should also understand what cannot be done using your wonderful toaster oven. 

Avoid Using Too Much Food

avoid using too much food

Whether baking brownies or something else, keep the amount to its minimum. 

No matter how tempting it feels, making a large frozen pizza in a toaster oven is risky business.

Because you’re probably going to be cooking it at a high temperature, if there’s too much food in it, the oven or stove will get quite hot. 

And the last thing you want is for your toaster to burst into flames. 

Never Try to Cook Raw Meat

raw meat in a microwave

Baking brownies and desserts are one thing, but do not take things too far and try to cook raw meat in there.

It may seem like a good idea to grab a steak from the supermarket and pop it in the toaster oven, but you would be making a huge error.

To begin, a toaster oven cannot replicate the smokey flavor of an authentic BBQ or grill, which is a major drawback. 

Also, if you still go ahead, you could end up with food poisoning due to the low heat used in the cooking process.

Tip: To avoid any health issues, you should only put already-cooked food into the toaster oven. 

Stay Away from Roasting Marshmallows

marshmallows in an oven

It may sound like fun, but do not try it. 

Know that it will take a lot longer than you think to roast marshmallows and you risk burning the whole thing if you use the highest heat setting.

Therefore, you should never use your new appliance to make s’mores. 

Make sure you stick to the things that can be baked in a typical oven. 

If you manage to burn something, at least this will keep things from getting too messed up.

Tip: Always keep an eye on your toaster oven when using it or you may run the risk of burning what you are baking. 


Can you make brownies in a toaster oven? Well, why not? 

In general, anything you can do in your conventional oven can surely be done in your toaster oven. 

Of course, you need to limit the quantity you want to bake. 

Interestingly, there are a whole lot of other things you can cook using your amazing toaster oven. 

So, let your inner chef break free now!