can i use beef stew seasoning for pot roast

Can I use beef stew seasoning for pot roast? You ask this when you love your stew but wonder if the same seasoning could be used for something else.

Stews are delicious.

When cooked at low, moist heat, even the toughest cuts of meat take on a desirable tenderness and luscious flavor in a stew.

Stews made with lean cuts of beef can quickly become dry, but those made with cuts that have some marbling and fluid connective tissue yield tender, luscious results.

And that taste heavily depends on seasoning.

The seasoning can enliven any dish, but is it okay to use beef stew seasoning for something else like pot roast?

Yes, you can certainly use beef stew seasoning for pot roast, but it ultimately comes down to personal preferences.

Tip: Be sure to cook pot roast at relatively higher temperatures to avoid gray, rubbery meat and get a golden-brown crust. 

Can I Use Beef Stew Seasoning for Pot Roast or Not?

use beef stew seasoning for pot roast

People’s ingenuity and resourcefulness have made it possible to whip up a wide range of tasty dishes with only a few basic ingredients.

And there is nothing compared to beef, as its versatility allows it to be used in a wide variety of recipes.

If you have always been in love with beef stew and even have your own special seasoning, you can also use it for pot roast.

However, it may have something to do with personal preferences.

But many people have confirmed that using beef stew seasoning for pot roast gives it a better flavor. 

What is the Difference Between Pot Roast and Beef Stew?

To better understand beef stew vs. pot roast seasoning, you need to know how both dishes are made.

The size of the meat is the primary distinction between Pot Roast and Beef Stew.

Large cuts of meat are slow-cooked in a sauce for this dish. Stew meat is diced into bite-sized pieces.

differences pot roast beef stew

Unlike traditional roasts, veggies in pot roast are not cooked alongside the meat but rather served as a side dish or garnish.

But in beef stew, the chunks of beef are cooked alongside vegetables.

It is quite obvious since stew implies a soupy consistency, and soups typically feature a mix of vegetables and meat.

Let’s have a closer look at both to understand the difference better. 

What is Pot Roast?

Pot roast is quite like the French special boeuf à la mode, which was heavily influenced by Jewish and German immigrants.

Essentially, it is a single cut of meat, such as chuck roast or brisket, that is slow-cooked in its own juices and eaten with gravy from the cooking pot.

Having its own gravy on the side helps keep it moist.

Although beef is the most popular choice, other meats such as chicken and turkey can be used.

Tip: Be sure to slice the meat against the grain to enjoy tender and delicious roasts. 
pot roast
How Do You Make Pot Roast?

Here is how you can make pot roast with utmost ease.

  1. Put in a preheated oven to 275-degree F.
  2. Sprinkle the chuck roast with salt and pepper liberally.
  3. Take some olive oil and heat in a big pot over medium heat.
  4. Cook the onion halves in the pot until they are golden on both sides.
  5. Take the onions and set them aside.
  6. Now add carrots to the pot and toss around for approximately a minute
  7. Use olive oil in the pot and sear the meat for no more than a minute.
  8. Sear on each side to achieve an even brown color.
  9. Put the roast on a serving dish.
  10. Deglaze the saucepan with beef broth or red wine.
  11. Now carefully scrape the bottom using a whisk while keeping the heat high.
  12. Return the roast to the pot followed by beef stock to cover it by half.
  13. Put in the fresh herbs, as well as the onions and carrots.
  14. Cover and roast for three hours to cook a three-pound roast.

The time needed to cook a roast weighing 4 to 5 pounds is 4 hours. When the roast starts falling apart, it is done. 

What is Beef Stew?

cooked beef stew

Beef stew consists of a variety of meats and vegetables that have been braised together in a sauce and then served over rice or noodles.

The major ingredients in this dish are chunks of beef and a wide range of vegetables, such as peppers, onions, potatoes, carrots, beans, and tomatoes.

All of these ingredients are cooked together over a moderate flame.

As a result, the stew is a slow-cooked food that resembles a thick and hearty soup in texture and flavor.

Tip: While water or canned broth would serve in a pinch, the secret to a delicious stew is in the broth. 
How Do You Make Beef Stew?
  • Dice the stew meat into bite-sized chunks. The excess fat must be cut out.
  • Toss the ingredients in a large bowl with the seasoned flour and coat them thoroughly.
  • Brown them in a skillet with some butter or oil until they are done. 

Can You Use the Same Seasoning for Beef Stew and Pot Roast?

use same seasoning

As you can see, the method of preparation is different, but ultimately, there are veggies and meat cooked together.

Therefore, using beef stew seasoning for your pot roast should not make a huge difference.  

However, you must be sure how much to use in different recipes.

Remember, a pot roast has a large piece of meat, so it takes longer to cook and has very little gravy.

You have a lot of gravy in a beef stew, so the amount of seasoning you use here would be different from what you use in your pot roast. 

Beef Stew and Pot Roast Seasoning Ideas

Although you can opt for read-to-use seasoning for beef stew and pot roast, you can always make your own.

So, what seasoning do you put in a beef stew? Find out now. 

Beef Stew Seasoning

beef dry seasoning

The beef stew will be much more flavorful thanks to this beef stew seasoning. It has a salty, savory, and sweet flavor.

We suggest you create an extra-large batch of this seasoning blend to ensure you have enough for a quick beef stew.

And you can also keep some to use for pot roast, if you want to. 

What Do You Need?
  • ½ tsp of Black pepper
  • 1 tsp of Dried rosemary
  • 1 tsp of Dried thyme
  • 1 tbsp of Garlic powder
  • ½ tsp of Smoked paprika
  • 1 tsp of Onion powder
  • 1 tsp of Salt
  • 1 tbsp of Brown sugar
  • 1 tbsp of White whole wheat flour
marinate beef with spices

You consider adding some spice, like 1/8 to ¼ tsp of chipotle pepper or cayenne pepper to give your beef stew some more power.

And of course, to make your seasoning more suitable if you want to use it for pot roast later. 

How to Prepare
  • Take a large glass container – a mason jar would work just fine too.
  • Add all the ingredients to the jar.
  • Stir the spices vigorously.
  • Seal the jar and store it in a dry place. 

How to Use Beef Stew Seasoning for Pot Roast?

how to use beef stew seasoning

Stop buying overpriced, single-use seasoning packets because you can make your own at home, and they will taste much better.

Pre-packaged seasonings may seem convenient, but they are also loaded with sodium and other potentially harmful ingredients.

You can simply use the beef stew seasoning you have just made and enjoy your pot roast even more. 

An Important Consideration

When using beef stew seasoning for pot roast, be sure to do it the night before you want to roast beef.

At least add salt and pepper to make a fast dry brine, basically. Taking this step will allow the seasoning to thoroughly penetrate the roast.

The roast can be marinated in the refrigerator by simply being rubbed with kosher salt, pepper, and any other spices you would like to add.

spices seasonings

Or, just apply the seasoning you have prepared at home and place it on a roasting pan. Refrigerate it, uncovered!

Tip: Stew uses tough cuts of meat packed with collagen so give it a lot of time after adding your seasoning to develop a great flavor. 


Whether you are totally in love with beef stew or cannot live with your pot roast, know that the right use of seasoning can make a huge difference.

Can I use beef stew seasoning for pot roast?

You definitely can, and it is actually a good idea because the pre-packaged seasoning is not always the best.

But you need to know how much to use and when to make both dishes taste amazing!